Prompt 30 — Physics invention promotion gate

Inputs

CANDIDATE: {{CANDIDATE_JSON}}
VALIDATION_REPORT: {{VALIDATION_REPORT_JSON}}
FALSIFIER_REPORT: {{FALSIFIER_REPORT_JSON}}
ONTOLOGY_REPORT: {{ONTOLOGY_REPORT_JSON}}
UTILITY_EVALUATION: {{UTILITY_EVALUATION_JSON}}
CONTAMINATION_REPORT: {{CONTAMINATION_REPORT_JSON}}
SAFETY_REPORT: {{SAFETY_REPORT_JSON}}
PARTITION_POLICY: {{PARTITION_POLICY_JSON}}
HUMAN_GATE_RECORD: {{HUMAN_GATE_RECORD_JSON}}

Task

Produce a promotion decision artifact. Do not modify the library.

Hard gates include:

• schema validity, stable identity, semantic version, and provenance;
• partition and visibility policy;
• explicit quantities, units, frames, assumptions, system boundary, and regimes;
• no false mathematical, numerical, empirical, causal, or replication claim;
• dependency closure or declared unresolved dependency;
• no unresolved blocker counterexample, alternative explanation, overfit, or evaluator exploit;
• independent validation appropriate to the claimed status;
• ontology and regime comparison completed;
• held-out utility evaluation completed for invented concepts or models;
• clean-room contamination audit passed when applicable;
• safety and dual-use gate passed at the released detail level;
• human gate completed when policy requires it.

Utility components must remain separate: predictive gain, compression, transfer, experiment-efficiency gain, interpretability, complexity cost, brittleness cost, and verification cost. No utility score may override a failed hard gate.

Allowed decisions: promote, promote_conditionally, retain_staging, repair, split, reject, or escalate.

Return only JSON matching schemas/promotion-decision.schema.json with applied: false.